COMPLAINTS IN COURTS: Examination of Powers of Magistrates under Sections 89, 90 and 111(b) of the Administration of Criminal Justice Law of Oyo State, 2016
COMPLAINTS IN COURTS: Examination of Powers of Magistrates under Sections 89, 90 and 111(b) of the Administration of Criminal Justice Law of Oyo State, 2016 Lecture delivered at the Lower Court Judges’ Seminar held at the Mini Conference Hall, High Court Complex, Ring Road, Ibadan 4th March 2020 2:00 pm. Adebayo Adenipekun, SAN, FCIArb. [Managing Partner, Afe Babalola & Co.] [Member, Permanent Court of Arbitration, The Hague, Netherlands] 80, Fajuyi Road, Ekotedo, Ibadan www.afebabalola.com INTRODUCTION: Before I delve into the substance of this lecture, I consider it a privilege to be invited to speak on this all-important topic in our criminal jurisprudence. My appreciation goes to the organizers, and by extension, the entire Oyo State magistracy, for considering it expedient to hold a seminar solely to deliberate on issues relating to the effectiveness of the Administration of Criminal Justice Law of Oyo State. This seminar is, indeed, a step in the right direction, not only to further ratify the existing synergy between the Bar and the Lower Bench, but also as an avenue for intellectual discourse on some of the provisions of the Administration of Criminal Justice Law of Oyo State. It is equally an avenue to share thoughts on the practicability and effectiveness of the Law of Oyo State in relation to the jurisdictional authority of the magistrate court. Magistrate Courts in Nigeria are the most important Courts when talking about the criminal justice system as more than 90% of criminal cases that get tried commence in the court (Pedro 2012) and 80% of those cases terminate in the magistrate courts (Yusuf Ali 2006). Unfortunately, the same court is relegated to the background by the managers of the system as allocation to the judicial sector is spent on other levels of the court system. No doubt, a proper implementation of the Administration of Criminal Justice Law will not only promote the efficient management of the criminal justice system and speedy dispensation of justice, but will also reduce the spate of criminality in Oyo State and ensure the protection of the rights of victims and suspects alike. Therefore, the topic being considered in this lecture, Complaints in Courts: Examination of Powers of Magistrates under Sections 89, 90 and 111(B) of the Administration of Criminal Justice Law of Oyo State, 2016, is one which is of paramount importance in our criminal jurisprudence as it seeks to appraise the powers of magistrates in Oyo State under sections 89, 90 and 111(b) of the Administration of Criminal Justice Law, 2016, and indeed some of the other relevant provisions, vis-à-vis one of the modes of instituting criminal proceedings – Complaint. INCREASE IN CRIMINALITY IN NIGERIA Criminality in Nigeria dates back to the nation’s pre-independence era; starting with simple and less organized delinquencies and gradually degenerating into complex and well-organized crimes that we have today. According to reports, Nigeria has one of the alarming crime rates in the world (Uche, 2008 and Financial, 2011). Causes of crimes have been attributed to biogenetic and socio-environmental factors. In the former, biogenetic factor, criminologists are opinioned that criminal activities are due to the effect of biologically caused or inherited factors. According to Lombrose (1911), a criminal is born, not made. In the latter, socio-environmental factors, the environment is said to play a significant role in determining criminal behaviour. Environmental factors which mostly influence criminal behaviour include poverty, unemployment, corruption, urbanization, family, moral decadence, non-education or undereducation, technology, child abuse, among others. Statistically, Nigeria currently has one of the highest crime rates in the world. After the erstwhile subtle rate of criminality in pre-independence Nigeria, the rate of crime took an alarming turn after independence, with the 1980s witnessing the growth of crime to nearly epidemic proportions, particularly in Lagos and other urbanized areas characterized by rapid growth and change, stark economic inequality and deprivation. Annual crime rates fluctuated at around 200 per 100,000 population until the early 1960s and then steadily increased to more than 300 per 100,000 by the mid-70s. Available data from the 1980s indicated a continuing increase. Total reported crime rose from almost 211,000 in 1981 to between 330,000 and 355,000 between 1984 – 85. The British High Commission in Lagos cited more than 3000 cases of forgery annually. In the early 1990s, there was a growing number of robberies from 1,937 in 1990 to 2,419 in 1996, and later, the figure declined to 2,291 in 1999. Throughout the 1990s, assault and theft constituted the later category of the crimes reported. Generally, the crime data grew from 244,354 in 1991 to 289,156 in 1993 (Cleen, 1993) and continued to decline from 241,091 in 1994 t0 167,492 in 1999 (Cleen, 2003). The number of crimes slightly declined to 162,039 in 2006, a reduction of 8% from 2005 (Cleen, 2006). Without a doubt, the current Nigerian economic and socio-political realities have engendered an astronomical increase in the spate of criminality, with ceaseless reports of kidnappings, ritual killings, acts of terrorism, domestic murders, among several others. COMBATING INCREASE IN CRIMINALITY THROUGH THE EFFECTIVE USE OF SECTIONS 89, 90 AND 111B OF THE ACJL 2016 The need to enact a law which conforms to current realities birthed the enactment of the Administration of Criminal Justice Law, 2016 as an effective tool in combating the flurry of criminality in Oyo State. According to its section 3, the purpose of the law is to promote speedy dispensation of justice, protection of the society from crime and protection of the rights and interests of the defendant and victim. Sections 89, 90 and 111b of the Law generally make provisions as to the right of any person, or his legal practitioner, to make a complaint to police officers or directly to the court, thereby instituting criminal proceedings where an offence is alleged. The sections equally make provisions for the power of a Magistrate to immediately issue summons or warrant of arrest to compel the presence of a person against whom a complaint is made. No doubt, these provisions are intended to facilitate easy access to

