Afe Babalola & Co

admin

Afe Babalola & Co petitions IG, Adamu over death of Ibadan businessman in police custody

Afe Babalola & Co petitions IG, Adamu over death of Ibadan businessman in police custody A legal luminary, Aare Afe Babalola, on Monday, petitioned the Inspector-General of Police, Mohammed Adamu, over the arrest and death of one Mr. Kehinde Omotosho. Afe Babalola in a petition made available to DAILY POST in Ibadan, the Oyo State capital, alleged that Omotosho was arrested and detained by some officers of the anti-cultism unit of the Oyo State Criminal Investigation Department last week. The legal luminary further explained that Omotosho was detained for six days without trial, the arrest which led to his death in police custody. Afe Babalola & Co in a petition signed by one of the lawyers in his chamber, Mr Oluwasina Ogungbade, appealed to Adamu to use his office to set up an investigation into the allegations contained in his petition. He said, “We are Solicitors to Miss Khadijat Omotosho (for herself and on behalf of other children of the late Mr Kehinde Omotosho), and gave her instructions to present to you, this Petition regarding the unlawful arrest, detention and eventual death of her father, Mr Kehinde Omotosho, (hereinafter referred to as the deceased) on 21st July 2020 while in the custody of the police officers attached to the Anti-Cultism Unit of the Oyo State Criminal Investigation Department, Iyaganku, Ibadan. As we shall subsequently detail, this Petition has been presented to request urgent investigation of not only the propriety of the arrest and detention of the deceased in lieu of another person for a period of 5 days until his eventual demise but also, more importantly, the circumstances surrounding his death which are rendered particularly suspicious and disturbing by a seeming attempt by certain Police Officials to cover up and distort the events leading up to this tragic incident. “In the early hours of Friday, 17th July 2020 (at about 12:30 am), several police officers from the Anti-Cultism Unit of the Oyo State CID stormed the residence of our clients’ father’s house at No. 2, Ifedapo Zone 2, Alaja Meta, Gbaremu, Idi-Obi, Ibadan, where the deceased resided alongside other tenants. The officers from the Anti-Cultism Unit were accompanied by some other police officers in Agugu Police Division, led by one officer identified simply as ‘SOJ’. On Monday, 20th July 2020, the deceased and Mr Jelili Razaq was brought before the Officer-in-Charge of the Anti-Cultism Unit for interview. In the course of the interview, the OC demanded that both the deceased and Mr Jelili Razaq produce their prime suspect, Mr Kabiru before they could be released. However, both the deceased and Mr Jelili Razaq informed the OC that they were all co-tenants and that Mr Kabiru had relocated to another place and did not inform them of his new location. Nevertheless, the OC insisted that their release would be consequent upon their production of Mr Kabiru. They were, thereafter, returned to the cell. It was at the point of this interview that the police informed the deceased and Mr Jelili Razaq that the prime suspect, Mr Kabiru, was involved in a fight, which led to the death of a person. There was however no suspicion or allegation that either the deceased or Mr Jelili Razaq were involved in the said fight or committed any crime whatsoever. “The following day, i.e. on 21st July at about 5 am, Mr Kehinde Omotosho, our clients’ father, died in police custody. Prior to his death, the deceased spent 5 days in detention while Mr Jelili Razaq spent 6 days before being released on bail, both without any investigation, reasonable suspicion of a crime, or arraignment. “From the moment of their arrest and until the death of the deceased, the officers of the Anti-Cultism Unit prevented the deceased’s and Mr Jelili Razaq’s family members from visiting them or providing them with food. Prior to his unlawful arrest, detention and death, the deceased had no underlying medical ailment”.But, Police Public Relations Officer of the State Police Command, Mr Olugbenga Fadeyi, while reacting, said that the deceased took ill in detention and was taken to the police clinic where he later died. Fadeyi added that autopsy will still be conducted on the deceased body so as to know the cause of death. “What happened was a clash between the OPC and some suspected cultist around Agugu area of Ibadan, which led to the death of someone, the arrest was made and some suspects arrested were screened according to the level of their involvement in the clash, the suspect might be detained more than 24 hours when it comes to the issue of murders and rape so as to do investigation properly.”

Afe Babalola & Co petitions IG, Adamu over death of Ibadan businessman in police custody Read More »

GROWING A BUDDING ADR PRACTICE: The Role of Mentors and Sponsors in ADR Practice

GROWING A BUDDING ADR PRACTICE: The Role of Mentors and Sponsors in ADR Practice INTRODUCTION I appreciate the organisers of this workshop – International Chamber of Commerce Young Arbitrators Forum (ICC YAF) for the opportunity to speak at this workshop.  I recognise every other speaker at this workshop and the amount of resource each speaker has offered at today’s workshop. At the risk of rehashing what has already been said earlier on, permit me to re-introduce the workshop’s theme. The theme of this session is “Growing a budding ADR Practice”. However, the focus of my discussion is as it pertains to “The Role of Mentors and Sponsors in ADR Practice”. This is a very timely discussion as the practice of ADR is becoming a very viable and attractive practice area. This is seeing the influx of a lot of young practitioners into the ADR scene. Practitioners interested in making a successful practice require to have discussions such as the instant one and this avenue is very much appreciated. WHAT IS ADR AND ADR PRACTICE? I cannot effectively do justice to this topic without briefly touching on the meaning of ADR and ADR Practice. Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) is a set of practices and techniques designed to facilitate the resolution of legal disputes outside the Courts system. It is a set of processes used in resolving disputes without the need to go to court. It can also be said to be a means of settling disputes by means other than litigation. It usually includes negotiation, mediation, arbitration, and a variety of other hybrid procedures involving a neutral party who facilitates the resolution of legal disputes without a formal adjudication, such as combining Mediation and Arbitration (Med-Arb). Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) may be preventive (negotiation, ADR clauses); facilitative (mediation); advisory (conciliation) or determinative (arbitration, Med-Arb, Arb-Med, and Adjudication). The practice of Alternative Dispute Resolution indicates a person’s involvement in the facilitation of alternative means of resolving disputes. ADR practice connotes the giving of legal advice or of representation of another as an agent in an ADR process, or in the preparation of legal documents to be used in the procedure. ADR practice can also be said to extend to playing the role of facilitating a mediation as a mediator, performing in advisory function as a conciliator or acting as an unbiased umpire in determining the rights of the parties, although outside of the institution of the court. As a lawyer, your role in ADR is diverse and therein presents the opportunities to grow a vibrant ADR practice. A lawyer may embrace the practice as a counsel or may play the role of resolving the dispute in some supervisory function. Either way, there appears to be an avenue to pursue a vibrant ADR practice. RELATED ARTICLE:  COMPLAINTS IN COURTS: examination of powers of magistrates under sections 89, 90 and 111(b) of the administration of criminal justice law of oyo state, 2016 GROWING A BUDDING ADR PRACTICE At this point, I believe that it would be appropriate to highlight some ideas on how to grow a budding ADR Practice. How can a lawyer build a career in ADR practice? How can he/she grow a budding practice? These are questions that may well be on the minds of a larger percentage of this paper’s audience. I have no doubt that previous speakers have touched on this broad topic. However, permit me to say a few words before I get to the nitty-gritty of my paper. Growing a budding ADR practice can be difficult as one may not know where to start from. The questions that may probe the mind are: how do I get the clients? What strategies should I invest in? What strategies should I avoid? How do I create the awareness that I am involved in ADR practice? How do I create an exposure for myself? How do I grow a budding ADR practice? There are many ways to grow a successful practice. At the outset, growth starts with setting a clearly defined goal on what you want to achieve. Growth can be intimidating and mean a lot of different things to several ADR practitioners, as growth is relative. At the outset, you must set out a clearly defined goal. This goal directs the trajectory with which you will build the practice. If you want your practice to revolve around the role of counsel or that of a third party such as an arbitrator, mediator or conciliator, setting out the goal early on provides a sense of direction and concentration of concerted efforts. In building a budding career in ADR practice, one must be proactive. When you are presented with a dispute, you could seize the opportunity to encourage your client to explore ADR. By so doing, you place yourself in the position to act as counsel to such a party in an ADR process. As a preventative measure, while advising clients with respect to an agreement or while drafting an agreement, you can ensure that you insert a dispute resolution clause in the agreement. These are some of the ways you can proactively position yourself to act as counsel in an ADR process. As a young ADR practitioner, one of the things you must do to ensure a budding ADR practice is to embrace continuing legal education. You must get trained. Spend money on training courses which will equip you for a vibrant ADR practice. Attend trainings and workshops. Be more interested in learning and building your craft. This will distinguish you from the flock. As a part of the trainings, you will realise that there are a number of professional bodies which offer trainings. Join these professional bodies and leverage on professional memberships. If I do not raise a caveat here, I should be expecting questions at the end of my talk to the effect that training alone does not provide guarantee of a budding practice. Indeed, training alone does not guarantee a budding practice. Other factors, as earlier identified, which

GROWING A BUDDING ADR PRACTICE: The Role of Mentors and Sponsors in ADR Practice Read More »

COMPLAINTS IN COURTS: Examination of Powers of Magistrates under Sections 89, 90 and 111(b) of the Administration of Criminal Justice Law of Oyo State, 2016

COMPLAINTS IN COURTS: Examination of Powers of Magistrates under Sections 89, 90 and 111(b) of the Administration of Criminal Justice Law of Oyo State, 2016 Lecture delivered at the Lower Court Judges’ Seminar held at the Mini Conference Hall, High Court Complex, Ring Road, Ibadan 4th March 2020 2:00 pm. Adebayo Adenipekun, SAN, FCIArb.   [Managing Partner, Afe Babalola & Co.] [Member, Permanent Court of Arbitration, The Hague, Netherlands] 80, Fajuyi Road, Ekotedo, Ibadan www.afebabalola.com INTRODUCTION: Before I delve into the substance of this lecture, I consider it a privilege to be invited to speak on this all-important topic in our criminal jurisprudence. My appreciation goes to the organizers, and by extension, the entire Oyo State magistracy, for considering it expedient to hold a seminar solely to deliberate on issues relating to the effectiveness of the Administration of Criminal Justice Law of Oyo State. This seminar is, indeed, a step in the right direction, not only to further ratify the existing synergy between the Bar and the Lower Bench, but also as an avenue for intellectual discourse on some of the provisions of the Administration of Criminal Justice Law of Oyo State. It is equally an avenue to share thoughts on the practicability and effectiveness of the Law of Oyo State in relation to the jurisdictional authority of the magistrate court. Magistrate Courts in Nigeria are the most important Courts when talking about the criminal justice system as more than 90% of criminal cases that get tried commence in the court (Pedro 2012) and 80% of those cases terminate in the magistrate courts (Yusuf Ali 2006). Unfortunately, the same court is relegated to the background by the managers of the system as allocation to the judicial sector is spent on other levels of the court system. No doubt, a proper implementation of the Administration of Criminal Justice Law will not only promote the efficient management of the criminal justice system and speedy dispensation of justice, but will also reduce the spate of criminality in Oyo State and ensure the protection of the rights of victims and suspects alike. Therefore, the topic being considered in this lecture, Complaints in Courts: Examination of Powers of Magistrates under Sections 89, 90 and 111(B) of the Administration of Criminal Justice Law of Oyo State, 2016, is one which is of paramount importance in our criminal jurisprudence as it seeks to appraise the powers of magistrates in Oyo State under sections 89, 90 and 111(b) of the Administration of Criminal Justice Law, 2016, and indeed some of the other relevant provisions, vis-à-vis one of the modes of instituting criminal proceedings – Complaint. INCREASE IN CRIMINALITY IN NIGERIA Criminality in Nigeria dates back to the nation’s pre-independence era; starting with simple and less organized delinquencies and gradually degenerating into complex and well-organized crimes that we have today. According to reports, Nigeria has one of the alarming crime rates in the world (Uche, 2008 and Financial, 2011). Causes of crimes have been attributed to biogenetic and socio-environmental factors. In the former, biogenetic factor, criminologists are opinioned that criminal activities are due to the effect of biologically caused or inherited factors. According to Lombrose (1911), a criminal is born, not made. In the latter, socio-environmental factors, the environment is said to play a significant role in determining criminal behaviour. Environmental factors which mostly influence criminal behaviour include poverty, unemployment, corruption, urbanization, family, moral decadence, non-education or undereducation, technology, child abuse, among others. Statistically, Nigeria currently has one of the highest crime rates in the world. After the erstwhile subtle rate of criminality in pre-independence Nigeria, the rate of crime took an alarming turn after independence, with the 1980s witnessing the growth of crime to nearly epidemic proportions, particularly in Lagos and other urbanized areas characterized by rapid growth and change, stark economic inequality and deprivation. Annual crime rates fluctuated at around 200 per 100,000 population until the early 1960s and then steadily increased to more than 300 per 100,000 by the mid-70s. Available data from the 1980s indicated a continuing increase. Total reported crime rose from almost 211,000 in 1981 to between 330,000 and 355,000 between 1984 – 85. The British High Commission in Lagos cited more than 3000 cases of forgery annually. In the early 1990s, there was a growing number of robberies from 1,937 in 1990 to 2,419 in 1996, and later, the figure declined to 2,291 in 1999. Throughout the 1990s, assault and theft constituted the later category of the crimes reported. Generally, the crime data grew from 244,354 in 1991 to 289,156 in 1993 (Cleen, 1993) and continued to decline from 241,091 in 1994 t0 167,492 in 1999 (Cleen, 2003). The number of crimes slightly declined to 162,039 in 2006, a reduction of 8% from 2005 (Cleen, 2006). Without a doubt, the current Nigerian economic and socio-political realities have engendered an astronomical increase in the spate of criminality, with ceaseless reports of kidnappings, ritual killings, acts of terrorism, domestic murders, among several others. COMBATING INCREASE IN CRIMINALITY THROUGH THE EFFECTIVE USE OF SECTIONS 89, 90 AND 111B OF THE ACJL 2016 The need to enact a law which conforms to current realities birthed the enactment of the Administration of Criminal Justice Law, 2016 as an effective tool in combating the flurry of criminality in Oyo State. According to its section 3, the purpose of the law is to promote speedy dispensation of justice, protection of the society from crime and protection of the rights and interests of the defendant and victim. Sections 89, 90 and 111b of the Law generally make provisions as to the right of any person, or his legal practitioner, to make a complaint to police officers or directly to the court, thereby instituting criminal proceedings where an offence is alleged. The sections equally make provisions for the power of a Magistrate to immediately issue summons or warrant of arrest to compel the presence of a person against whom a complaint is made. No doubt, these provisions are intended to facilitate easy access to

COMPLAINTS IN COURTS: Examination of Powers of Magistrates under Sections 89, 90 and 111(b) of the Administration of Criminal Justice Law of Oyo State, 2016 Read More »

a

Finality of Arbitral Awards in Nigeria- Separating Harm from Hubris (Contd.)

Finality of Arbitral Awards in Nigeria- Separating Harm from Hubris (Contd.) In a previous post, the issue of finality of arbitral awards in Nigeria was discussed and it was concluded that the review of awards is not in itself a vice to arbitration. In this post, I share further observations on the finality debacle with emphasis on the pro-finality judicial policy in Nigeria. Are our Criticisms Fair?: There is an increasing crop of arbitration practitioners making it to the state and federal benches in Nigeria and taking with them a firm understanding of arbitration law and the limitations of judicial intervention. Courts have generally warmed up to arbitration and the finality of its awards. Thus, the risk of overreach in Nigerian courts has reduced. Of course, there is the notorious Nigerian case of Taylor Woodrow (Nig.) Ltd. v. Suddeutsehe Etna – Werk GMBH (1993) 4 NWLR (Pt. 286) 127, which has been much vilified for two reasons. Firstly, the decision appeared to expand the grounds for challenge of an award by a wide margin. Secondly, the decision takes cognisance of errors of law and mistakes of fact as grounds to set aside an award – a large leeway for re-litigation. Worse, the decision is that of the Supreme Court in a country where judicial precedent is the law. I too have had bad experiences arising from this decision as I have seen so many challenge applications based on even the most frivolous points and by imaginative legal argumentation, hinged to any of the ten misconduct examples in Taylor Woodrow. To be fair, however, complaints of errors of law are an exception – the Learned Law Lords of the Supreme Court did state the law as is applicable in Nigeria today, that “You have constituted your own tribunal; you are bound by its decision’. The only exceptions to that rule, are, cases where the award is the result of corruption or fraud, and one other, which, though it is to be regretted, is now, I think, firmly established, viz: where the question of law necessarily arises on the face of the award, or upon some paper accompanying and forming part of the award. The Learned Justices adopted this exception, as can be seen, with reluctance and it is important to understand that this exception was not a creation of the Nigerian Courts- the Supreme Court had merely followed the English position as in Hodgkinson v. Fernie. That decision may no longer be the law in England as a result of legislation but as the Nigerian Arbitration and Conciliation Act has remained the same since Taylor Woodrow, the position remains. However, Taylor Woodrow does not appear to me to have materially altered the law since in 2015 the Court of Appeal would still hold that on the question of errors of law, “when parties have referred a question to a judge of their choice…they must be bound by his decision whether the conclusion be right or wrong” (Arbico v. Nigeria Machine Tools). An error of law contemplated by Taylor Woodrow will arise only where the legal question is the main dispute submitted for resolution to the arbitrator. A mistake of fact, on the other hand, was explained to be one that is admitted or clear beyond reasonable doubt. Proof beyond reasonable doubt is the highest standard of proof in Nigeria and to my knowledge, no challenge application on mistake of fact has met that standard yet. Most gratifying on award finality is the decision of the Nigerian Supreme Court delivered in January 2017 in NITEL v. Okeke [2017] 9 NWLR (Pt. 1571) 439. A complaint of the appellant was that the arbitrator had not considered the evidence the way a judicial panel would have and that the tribunal did not analyse the pleadings as a court would. The Supreme Court rejected this argument and held that “[a] court should not therefore upset the expectation of the parties except for the clearest evidence of wrong doing or manifest illegality on the part of the arbitrator”. The Supreme Court stated expressly that a challenge application is not a merits appeal and deprecated the appellant’s approach of attacking the substance of the award rather than demonstrating the alleged misconduct. Fortunately, the Court considered Taylor Woodrow and was not persuaded that the conduct of the arbitrator in question fit into any of the broad Taylor Woodrow examples of misconduct. Accordingly, Taylor Woodrow may make for easy criticism but it does not appear that it has significantly altered the law on award finality – an award is still final and binding in Nigeria, whether its conclusion be right or wrong. Of course, the criticism against Taylor Woodrow is not really that it altered the law but that it has led to a deluge of mischievous actions to set awards aside. The problem with this criticism is in its very framing – if an application is mischievous or made with a hidden untoward intent, the state of the law is essentially immaterial and even if the Nigerian law were to be interpreted or amended to reduce the ground of challenge to one stringent ground, mischievous party representatives will still bring applications to set awards aside and tie them to that sole statutory ground. The problem is, therefore, the mischief of the party representatives and not the courts. And if the position in Taylor Woodrow is no longer the law in England because legislation has changed the challenge landscape, then blame should lie at the feet of the Nigerian legislature, not the courts. Certainly, a panacea for the criticisms is perhaps in the clamour for an effective judicial system in Nigeria where challenge applications are heard timeously and effectively as opposed to the current norm where challenge applications even when ultimately refused, stay in courts for long periods, sometimes as long as a decade. The point is, for arbitrators, the concern ought not to be the litigious nature of party representatives but the judicial policy of Nigeria. The law as it is may disappoint the party-representative and arbitration user

Finality of Arbitral Awards in Nigeria- Separating Harm from Hubris (Contd.) Read More »

Come in, Let’s Arbitrate: The Rise and Rise of Arbitration in Nigeria

We aim to lead in each practice and area of law we work in. Coming from in-depth understanding of the law and the industry, capitalizing on extensive experience, we provide hands-on advice that speaks the language of our client’s business. Whether in aviation, sales and distribution, antitrust, corporate and M&A, finance, employment, energy, IP, litigation, TMT, real estate, or any other area of law, our clients can expect excellence and commitment to their objectives. Ensuring the operational functioning of the organisation, the development of external relations, management of press relations and constant communication with the press.

Come in, Let’s Arbitrate: The Rise and Rise of Arbitration in Nigeria Read More »

Ligobetgrandpashabet girişdeneme bonusudeneme bonusujojobet girişdeneme bonusudeneme bonusu veren sitelerdeneme bonusudeneme bonusu veren sitelergrandpashabetgrandpashabet deneme bonusugrandpashabet girişDeneme Bonusu Veren Sitelerdeneme bonusugrandpashabet girişgrandpashabetgrandpashabet güncel girişdeneme bonusugrandpashabethttps://centromedicoflorence.com/cookies-service/betkommarsbahisbahis siteleribahis siteleriGrandpashabet girişjojobetjojobetjojobet giriş