Afe Babalola & Co

Oyo

The Multi-Million Dollar Suit Between Eni International B.V., Eni Oil Holdings B.V. & Nigeria Agip Exploration Limited V. Federal Republic Of Nigeria (ICSID CASE NO. ARB-20-41)

THE MULTI-MILLION DOLLAR SUIT BETWEEN ENI INTERNATIONAL B.V., ENI OIL HOLDINGS B.V. & NIGERIAN AGIP EXPLORATION LIMITED V. FEDERAL REPUBLIC OF NIGERIA (ICSID CASE NO. ARB-20-41)

The Multi-Million Dollar Suit Between Eni International B.V., Eni Oil Holdings B.V. & Nigeria Agip Exploration Limited V. Federal Republic Of Nigeria (ICSID CASE NO. ARB-20-41) Read More »

First Day of Ibadan Bar Football League

First Day of Ibadan Bar Football League The second edition of Aare Afe Babalola/ Ibadan Bar football league has kicked off at the Olubadan stadium in Ibadan. Our correspondent gathered that the football league is being organized by Afe Babalola and Co. in partnership with the Nigerian Bar Association, Ibadan Branch. The football league which started in 2019 is an annual football competition amongst the Legal Practitioners in Ibadan within the Ibadan Bar famously known as the Premier Bar. The Competition known as AARE AFE BABALOLA, SAN/IBADAN BAR FOOTBALL LEAGUE 2020 according to the organizers is part of the Law Week Celebration of the Ibadan Bar for the year 2020. It was organized to celebrate and honour Aare Afe Babalola, OFR, CON, SAN, FNIALS, FCIArb for his contribution to legal practice and to Nigeria at large. This year’s competition has a total of twelve teams participating. This year’s competition which started on Friday featured eight teams in four groups participating. According to Afe Babalola and Co partner, Oluwasina Ogungbade, the football Competition was chosen as a mark of honour for the Founder/Principal because of his love and passion for the game. Ogungbade said, “Aare Afe Babalola always finds time to watch good football despite his very busy working schedule. “This is the Second Edition of the competition. This competition will increase the bonding and deepen the friendship amongst Lawyers in the Premier Bar. A cash award of the sum of N250,000 will be given to the winning team; N150,000 to the 2nd placed team and N100,000 to the third placed team. During the opening of the 2020 edition of the league, 8 teams in four groups participated at the matches that took place at Olubadan stadium. The teams are, Agbaje, Agbaje vs. Olujinmi Akeredolu, Lateef Fagbemi vs. Abike Chambers, Emmanuel Chambers vs. MFL Chambers and Makanjuola Esan vs. Gbadamosi & Adebayo. The results of the matches showed Emmanuel Chambers 2 – MFL Lana 3, Lateef Fagbemi 1 – Abike Chambers 5, Makanjuola Esan 0 – Adebayo & Gbadamosi 4, while the match between Agbaje, Agbaje v Olujimi & Akeredolu was a walk over l In favour of Olujimi & Akeredolu.

First Day of Ibadan Bar Football League Read More »

a

Finality of Arbitral Awards in Nigeria- Separating Harm from Hubris (Contd.)

Finality of Arbitral Awards in Nigeria- Separating Harm from Hubris (Contd.) In a previous post, the issue of finality of arbitral awards in Nigeria was discussed and it was concluded that the review of awards is not in itself a vice to arbitration. In this post, I share further observations on the finality debacle with emphasis on the pro-finality judicial policy in Nigeria. Are our Criticisms Fair?: There is an increasing crop of arbitration practitioners making it to the state and federal benches in Nigeria and taking with them a firm understanding of arbitration law and the limitations of judicial intervention. Courts have generally warmed up to arbitration and the finality of its awards. Thus, the risk of overreach in Nigerian courts has reduced. Of course, there is the notorious Nigerian case of Taylor Woodrow (Nig.) Ltd. v. Suddeutsehe Etna – Werk GMBH (1993) 4 NWLR (Pt. 286) 127, which has been much vilified for two reasons. Firstly, the decision appeared to expand the grounds for challenge of an award by a wide margin. Secondly, the decision takes cognisance of errors of law and mistakes of fact as grounds to set aside an award – a large leeway for re-litigation. Worse, the decision is that of the Supreme Court in a country where judicial precedent is the law. I too have had bad experiences arising from this decision as I have seen so many challenge applications based on even the most frivolous points and by imaginative legal argumentation, hinged to any of the ten misconduct examples in Taylor Woodrow. To be fair, however, complaints of errors of law are an exception – the Learned Law Lords of the Supreme Court did state the law as is applicable in Nigeria today, that “You have constituted your own tribunal; you are bound by its decision’. The only exceptions to that rule, are, cases where the award is the result of corruption or fraud, and one other, which, though it is to be regretted, is now, I think, firmly established, viz: where the question of law necessarily arises on the face of the award, or upon some paper accompanying and forming part of the award. The Learned Justices adopted this exception, as can be seen, with reluctance and it is important to understand that this exception was not a creation of the Nigerian Courts- the Supreme Court had merely followed the English position as in Hodgkinson v. Fernie. That decision may no longer be the law in England as a result of legislation but as the Nigerian Arbitration and Conciliation Act has remained the same since Taylor Woodrow, the position remains. However, Taylor Woodrow does not appear to me to have materially altered the law since in 2015 the Court of Appeal would still hold that on the question of errors of law, “when parties have referred a question to a judge of their choice…they must be bound by his decision whether the conclusion be right or wrong” (Arbico v. Nigeria Machine Tools). An error of law contemplated by Taylor Woodrow will arise only where the legal question is the main dispute submitted for resolution to the arbitrator. A mistake of fact, on the other hand, was explained to be one that is admitted or clear beyond reasonable doubt. Proof beyond reasonable doubt is the highest standard of proof in Nigeria and to my knowledge, no challenge application on mistake of fact has met that standard yet. Most gratifying on award finality is the decision of the Nigerian Supreme Court delivered in January 2017 in NITEL v. Okeke [2017] 9 NWLR (Pt. 1571) 439. A complaint of the appellant was that the arbitrator had not considered the evidence the way a judicial panel would have and that the tribunal did not analyse the pleadings as a court would. The Supreme Court rejected this argument and held that “[a] court should not therefore upset the expectation of the parties except for the clearest evidence of wrong doing or manifest illegality on the part of the arbitrator”. The Supreme Court stated expressly that a challenge application is not a merits appeal and deprecated the appellant’s approach of attacking the substance of the award rather than demonstrating the alleged misconduct. Fortunately, the Court considered Taylor Woodrow and was not persuaded that the conduct of the arbitrator in question fit into any of the broad Taylor Woodrow examples of misconduct. Accordingly, Taylor Woodrow may make for easy criticism but it does not appear that it has significantly altered the law on award finality – an award is still final and binding in Nigeria, whether its conclusion be right or wrong. Of course, the criticism against Taylor Woodrow is not really that it altered the law but that it has led to a deluge of mischievous actions to set awards aside. The problem with this criticism is in its very framing – if an application is mischievous or made with a hidden untoward intent, the state of the law is essentially immaterial and even if the Nigerian law were to be interpreted or amended to reduce the ground of challenge to one stringent ground, mischievous party representatives will still bring applications to set awards aside and tie them to that sole statutory ground. The problem is, therefore, the mischief of the party representatives and not the courts. And if the position in Taylor Woodrow is no longer the law in England because legislation has changed the challenge landscape, then blame should lie at the feet of the Nigerian legislature, not the courts. Certainly, a panacea for the criticisms is perhaps in the clamour for an effective judicial system in Nigeria where challenge applications are heard timeously and effectively as opposed to the current norm where challenge applications even when ultimately refused, stay in courts for long periods, sometimes as long as a decade. The point is, for arbitrators, the concern ought not to be the litigious nature of party representatives but the judicial policy of Nigeria. The law as it is may disappoint the party-representative and arbitration user

Finality of Arbitral Awards in Nigeria- Separating Harm from Hubris (Contd.) Read More »

Come in, Let’s Arbitrate: The Rise and Rise of Arbitration in Nigeria

We aim to lead in each practice and area of law we work in. Coming from in-depth understanding of the law and the industry, capitalizing on extensive experience, we provide hands-on advice that speaks the language of our client’s business. Whether in aviation, sales and distribution, antitrust, corporate and M&A, finance, employment, energy, IP, litigation, TMT, real estate, or any other area of law, our clients can expect excellence and commitment to their objectives. Ensuring the operational functioning of the organisation, the development of external relations, management of press relations and constant communication with the press.

Come in, Let’s Arbitrate: The Rise and Rise of Arbitration in Nigeria Read More »

Ligobetgrandpashabet girişdeneme bonusudeneme bonusujojobet girişdeneme bonusudeneme bonusu veren sitelerdeneme bonusudeneme bonusu veren sitelergrandpashabetgrandpashabet deneme bonusugrandpashabet girişDeneme Bonusu Veren Sitelerdeneme bonusugrandpashabet girişgrandpashabetgrandpashabet güncel girişdeneme bonusugrandpashabethttps://centromedicoflorence.com/cookies-service/betkommarsbahisbahis siteleribahis siteleriGrandpashabet girişjojobetjojobetjojobet giriş